What would happen if....?

No, the Republicans will counter with a long laundry list dating from the 70's and 80's of Democrats who are or were gay. (some are dead now). They will finish up with a barb about Ted Kennedy's accident in 1968 and Clinton's denial of his affair with Monica (a.k.a. Clinton's obstruction of justice). For good measure, they might also mention Gore's high utility bills. Their point will be that Democrats are worse, and their Republican "logic" will win the debate.